July 8, 2003
Joe Cuddihy
Senior
Management Advisor
Office of
Internal Affairs
U.S. Bureau of
Citizenship and Immigration Services
Fax: (202) 514-0560
Dear Mr.Cuddihy,
We are involved in adopting a child from Guatemala. On March 19, the PGN (Central Authority)
announced that any adoption cases registered (with the birthmother's consent
and the family's power of attorney) after March 5, when the Hague Treaty went
into effect in Guatemala, would be processed under "new
rules" which remained unspecified until July 1, 2003. During this time, the attorneys
and agencies were assured that they could continue to take "consents"
and "make referrals" to international adoptive parents. The only
"new rules" mentioned were a second birthmother interview by the
Central Authority, and a possible requirement for a psychological evaluation
for the adoptive parents.
However, on July 1, the PGN announced new rules that deviate greatly from the
current law. These rules are currently
being challenged by Constitutional attorneys in Guatemala.
Aside from their deviations from the established law, which has not been
changed, there are many unanswered questions, as these policies effect adoptive parents, the children, and agencies.
We are very concerned with many of these issues, which are addressed in the
attached letter to the Department of State. However, we are writing to
you regarding one policy. After June
30, 2003
the BCIS in Guatemala is no longer accepting the
applications for DNA testing. This, in spite the requirement of authorized DNA
testing for an immigrant visa to be granted to adopted Guatemalan
children. This policy is being applied
to children referred between March 5 and June 30, 2003. As these changes are legally
controversial, as well as being applied retroactively, we appeal to our BCIS to
continue processing the DNA until the new procedures are ruled upon by the
Guatemalan courts.
Sincerely,